Why a Roth Conversion May Make Sense
Costs that rise with retirement income
In retirement, extra taxable income can cost more than your bracket suggests. Traditional IRA and 401(k) withdrawals count toward these thresholds. Qualified Roth withdrawals do not.
|
Cost |
2026 threshold (single / joint) |
Impact |
|---|---|---|
|
Medicare IRMAA |
MAGI above $109,000 / $218,000 (two-year lookback) |
Part B up to $608.10/mo vs. $202.90, plus up to $91/mo on Part D, per person |
|
Senior deduction phase-out |
MAGI above $75,000 / $150,000 |
Lose up to $6,000 per person 65+ |
|
Net investment income tax |
MAGI above $200,000 / $250,000 |
Extra 3.8% on investment income |
|
Social Security taxation |
Provisional income above $34,000 / $44,000 |
Up to 85% of benefits taxable |
|
Capital gains rates |
Rise with taxable income |
Long-term gains move from 0% to 15% to 20% |
|
ACA subsidy cliff (pre-65) |
Above 400% of poverty level |
Entire premium credit lost |
A hidden trap: municipal bond interest. Tax-exempt interest isn't taxed itself, but it still counts toward the income used for IRMAA and for taxing Social Security benefits.
The widow's penalty
After the year a spouse dies, most survivors file as single. Income often drops only a little, since RMDs continue. But the thresholds are roughly cut in half: the 24% bracket starts at $105,700 of taxable income instead of $211,400, and IRMAA at $109,000 instead of $218,000.
Hypothetical: A couple with $150,000 of taxable income owes about $22,400 in 2026 federal tax. A survivor with $130,000 owes about $23,800, which is more tax on less income. (Federal brackets only; for illustration, not an actual client.)
For higher-income households
These additional costs apply mainly to larger incomes or to households that itemize deductions.
|
Cost |
2026 threshold |
Impact |
|---|---|---|
|
Alternative minimum tax (AMT) |
Exemption phases out above $500,000 single / $1,000,000 joint |
Exemption ($90,100 / $140,200) shrinks 50¢ per dollar over the threshold |
|
Itemized deduction limit |
37% bracket |
Itemized deductions are worth at most 35% |
|
Charitable deduction floor |
0.5% of AGI (itemizers) |
Gifts below the floor aren't deductible; IRA charitable distributions (from age 70½) avoid it |
|
SALT deduction phase-down |
MAGI above $505,000 |
$40,400 cap shrinks toward $10,000 |
|
Medical expense floor |
7.5% of AGI |
Higher AGI means less of large costs, such as long-term care, is deductible |
|
Rental loss allowance |
MAGI $100,000–$150,000 (not indexed) |
Up to $25,000 of rental losses phases out |
|
Additional Medicare tax |
Wages above $200,000 / $250,000 |
Extra 0.9% if still working or self-employed |
A large Roth conversion or capital gain can push income into these ranges for that year, so conversion amounts should be sized with them in mind.
How a Roth conversion may help
You pay tax on the converted amount now; qualified withdrawals later are tax-free, and Roth IRAs have no RMDs for the owner. The years between retiring and starting RMDs (age 73, or 75 if born 1960 or later) are often the lowest-income window to convert.
- Fill lower brackets now rather than risk higher rates later.
- Shrink future RMDs to stay under IRMAA, NIIT, and other thresholds.
- Protect a surviving spouse by paying tax at joint rates instead of single.
- Leave heirs assets they can generally withdraw tax-free.
Trade-offs: The tax is due now and is best paid from non-IRA funds. A conversion raises this year's MAGI, which can affect IRMAA two years later and ACA subsidies before 65. Conversions can't be undone, five-year rules apply, and tax laws can change. It may not make sense if you expect lower future tax rates or plan to leave the IRA to charity.